Investors starting to turn back on clean energy
- September 21, 2023
- Posted by: Quatro Strategies
- Category: ESG & Renewable Energy
In a somewhat surprising turn of events, investors have withdrawn a record amount of money from the world’s largest clean energy investment vehicles during the first eight months of this year. A net total of $765 million was withdrawn from the iShares Global Clean Energy ETF (ICLN), marking a substantial outflow and a record for any January to August period.
Another clean energy ETF, the First Trust NASDAQ Clean Edge Green Energy Index (QLN), experienced a net outflow of $197 million, while the VanEck Low Carbon Energy ETF (SMOG) saw a net withdrawal of $23.6 million. The trend seems to be a shift in investor preference toward sectors like artificial intelligence (AI), prompting a move away from energy investments.
One of the main contributors to this trend is the attractiveness of sectors like AI. The Global X Robotics & Artificial Intelligence ETF (BOTZ), the largest ETF in the AI space, witnessed substantial net inflows of over $614 million through August, the highest for that fund during that period since 2018. The clean energy sector had outperformed other sectors, including technology, over the past two years, making it a likely target for some investors to reallocate their holdings and join the AI rush.
However, significant disappointments within the clean energy industry have also impacted investor confidence. The wind power sector, in particular, faced disappointing national offshore auction results in Britain and the United States, contributing to this downturn. The European solar industry raised concerns about a challenging situation for solar photovoltaic (PV) manufacturers due to plummeting PV prices.
Even the electric vehicle (EV) market, seen as a bright spot in the energy transition, encountered potential hurdles. The European Commission threatened an investigation into subsidies for Chinese EV makers, causing uncertainty in a market where they have been gaining market share at the expense of European automakers.
Despite these challenges, the broader push for cleaner energy sources continues to have widespread support at societal, political, and corporate levels. Investors, especially long-term ones, are likely to remain interested in clean energy, and even modest success stories tied to government or corporate renewable energy projects could reverse the recent fund flow trends from outbound to inbound.
The price drop in major clean energy ETFs, reaching their lowest levels in over three years, might be viewed as an attractive entry point for potential investors, considering the ongoing support and investment into the broader energy transition. Ultimately, while investors in ETFs and other funds play a role, they are not the main drivers of the global energy transition, which is set to continue regardless of short-term investment trends. The shifts in fund flows do, however, provide insights into broader sentiment within the clean energy sector, which could rebound once positive earnings and development auction results start to materialize.
By QUATRO Strategies International Inc.
QUATRO Strategies International Inc. is the leading business insights and corporate strategy company based in Toronto, Ontario. Through our unique services, we counsel our clients on their key strategic issues, leveraging our deep industry expertise and using analytical rigor to help them make informed decisions to establish a competitive edge in the marketplace.
Interested in learning more?
Sign up for Top Insights Today
Top Insights Today delivers the latest insights straight to your inbox.
You will get daily industry insights on
Oil & Gas, Rare Earths & Commodities, Mining & Metals, EVs & Battery Technology, ESG & Renewable Energy, AI & Semiconductors, Aerospace & Defense, Sanctions & Regulation, Business & Politics.
Read more insights
Indonesia’s nickel boom runs into China’s LFP wall
China and Indonesia have, together, created one of the most dramatic mining stories of the past decade, and now they’re discovering that demand doesn’t always show up in the form you planned for. Backed by Chinese capital, engineering and offtake agreements, Indonesia turned itself from a bit player in nickel into the undisputed giant of the market in barely ten years.
The country’s output exploded from under a million tonnes in 2020 to roughly 2.3 million tonnes today, lifting its global share from about 30% to around 70%. At first, this boom was all about stainless steel: Indonesian ore fed Chinese blast furnaces, and after Jakarta banned exports of raw ore in 2020, the trade shifted into nickel pig iron, feeding China’s huge metals complex.
Norway launches first seabed mineral licensing round amid green transition push
Norway has launched its inaugural seabed mineral licensing round, offering large areas of the Arctic region for exploration and aiming to award permits by the first half of 2025, according to the country’s energy ministry. If successful, Norway could become the first nation to commence commercial deep-sea mining, targeting…
Iraq lures Exxon back as Baghdad rebuilds ties with Western majors
Exxon Mobil is set to re-enter Iraq with a framework deal centered on the Majnoon field and southern export systems, an about-face two years after winding down major Iraqi positions. Baghdad has been courting the supermajors with sweeter terms, and the Exxon accord, while still non-binding, signals that the new fiscal and operational package is enticing enough to overcome the hurdles that chased Western firms away: thin returns, governance frictions, and chronic infrastructure bottlenecks.
The agreement, as described by Iraqi officials and industry sources, goes beyond upstream barrels. It pairs profit-sharing on crude and refined products with upgrades to export capacity around Basra, and folds in storage arrangements in Asia via SOMO and Exxon, giving Iraq optionality to manage flows, smooth differentials, and target premium markets.